Decision Guide

Repair or Replace Your Mississauga Water Heater?

Four questions settle it: who owns the tank, what failed, how old it is and how the repair quote compares with a new tank.

SD Editorial
ServiceDispatch Editorial Team ServiceDispatch.ca
Written for Mississauga, ON

Repair the water heater when a single part has failed on a fairly young tank. The quote should be well below half the price of a new one. Replace it when the tank wall leaks, the tank is old or repairs keep following one another. In Mississauga most homeowners pay about $1,500 to $2,800 for a new gas tank with a conventional vent, installed. That is the number to hold a repair quote against. A rented tank adds an opening question. What does the agreement say about repairs and replacement?

Question 1: Do You Own the Tank?

If it is rented, call the rental company first, because its terms usually decide what happens. When it offers a replacement, get the monthly rate, the length of the new term and any cancellation charge in writing. Ontario bans selling water heaters at the door unless you made the first contact, and a contract can be cancelled for 10 days after you receive it in writing. Rental companies do not publish a buyout price, so ask for one in writing and compare it with a new tank bought outright.

Question 2: Which Part Failed?

The failed part counts for more than the symptom. A tank wall that has rusted through cannot be mended, but most other faults can.

ProblemVerdictCost
Water seeping through the tank wall, all fittings dryReplace at any ageCannot be repaired
Dripping relief valveRepairAbout $100 to $350
Thermocouple on a gas tankRepairAbout $100 to $300
Electric elementRepair on a younger tankAbout $150 to $300
ThermostatDepends on ageAbout $150 to $350
Anode rodRepair if the tank wall is soundAbout $150 to $400

Ask for parts and labour as separate lines, and ask whether HST is included.

Question 3: How Old Is It?

Fixing a part leaves the tank as old as it was. The serial number on the rating label gives the date, and a tank well into its second decade has little life in hand. About 38 percent of Mississauga's homes were built in 1980 or earlier, so plenty of tanks sit beside old plumbing, where one failure is often followed by another.

Question 4: Is the Quote Over Half the Price of a New Tank?

Once a repair costs more than half of a replacement, buying a new tank is the better use of the money. With a new gas tank at about $1,500 to $2,800 installed, half comes to about $750 to $1,400. A young tank rarely reaches that with one part, but a string of repairs on an old one can get there fast.

How Local Water Tips the Balance

South Peel's water is moderately hard, 120 to 130 mg/L, so scale builds at a moderate rate. A young tank that has been flushed is usually worth repairing. One that has never been flushed likely carries a thick layer on the bottom, and that can tip a borderline decision toward replacing it. Water heater maintenance in Mississauga explains the yearly flush.

If You Replace

If you smell gas, get out of the house and call Enbridge Gas on 1-866-763-5427 or 911 from a safe place.

Put It in Writing

Also useful: signs a water heater needs replacing, and for a tank that is already dripping, what to do about a leaking water heater.

Directory · 4 companies

Top-rated water heater companies in Mississauga

Independently selected on Google rating, review volume and years in Mississauga. Every company here is rated 4.7 or higher. Tap one to open its Google listing, with phone number, hours and recent reviews.

  1. Glors Heating and Air Conditioning

    4.9 · 530+ Google reviews

    Founder-led Mississauga company on Pate Court. Furnaces, air conditioning, boilers and water heaters, including tankless.

    View on Google
  2. Furnace King Home Services

    4.9 · 940+ Google reviews

    Mississauga company on Mattawa Avenue. Furnaces, air conditioning, heat pumps, boilers and water heaters, including tankless.

    View on Google
  3. HVAC-Group

    5.0 · 280+ Google reviews

    Mississauga heating and cooling company. Furnaces, air conditioning, heat pumps, boilers and water heaters.

    View on Google
  4. Tamas Mechanical

    4.9 · 210+ Google reviews

    Mississauga heating and cooling company. Furnaces, air conditioning, heat pumps, boilers, water heaters and HRVs.

    View on Google

Frequently Asked Questions

Usually, if the tank is fairly young and the repair costs less than half of a new one. Nobody should repair a leak through the tank wall.

Only when the water comes through the tank wall. A valve or a fitting that drips can be repaired.

Rarely. On a tank well beyond ten years, even a small repair buys little extra time, so get a replacement quote before you decide.

Do the sums. A gas tank with a conventional vent rents from about $26 to $31 a month plus HST, which is roughly $3,360 over 10 years at $28 a month, against about $1,500 to $2,800 to buy and have installed.

It costs a lot more up front, about $3,000 to $5,500 installed, so it only makes sense when you want one regardless. Tankless water heaters in Mississauga goes through it.

See Top-Rated Companies